Fear causes us to adhere religiously to the logical flat-plane surface that is provided for us by the thinking mind. This logical surface is our refuge from fear, our escape from it. When we come across someone who is adhering to thought’s representation of the world in a ‘religious’ fashion like this we say that they are exhibiting ‘concrete thinking’, and this concreticity strikes us straightaway (we can’t not notice it), whilst the person themselves – of course – simply takes the concrete way they are for granted and has no way to notice it. There is nothing remarkable about it at all, to them. When we are in ‘Concrete Mode’ we don’t notice that we are afraid either (which is why it functions as an escape). If we knew we were hiding from fear then we wouldn’t be hiding very successfully. The concrete mode of existence is the perfect answer to fear, we might therefore say.
Krishnamurti says that it’s not the advent of the new that we are afraid of but the end of the old and – this being this case – we can see that the way fear works is by causing us resisting change, by clinging on the known, by tirelessly asserting and reasserting the past, and so on and so forth. Concrete mode is conservative mode. If what we’re afraid of is the ending of the known, then the way fear will show itself is in terms of conservatism. We’re going to get as much mileage out of the known as we possibly can, we’re going to stretch it out to the very limit of how far it will go. We will stretch it because of our fear, and just as we’re able to keep going with the stretching (just as long as we can continue holding on to the old) then we won’t know that we are afraid. We’re bringing our frame of reference with us wherever we go, and so we can be sure that, no matter what else might happen, we’ll never have to let go of the world that we know (or ‘the world as we know it’). We will never have to ‘let go’ full stop,
When we talk about ‘adhering to the logical surface provided for us by thought’ this is what we’re on about, therefore – as long as there is a continuous series of problems (or logical challenges) for us to get to grips with then we’ll never have to deal with anything radically new, we can just chug along mechanically, essentially doing the same basic thing over and over again. This might sound tedious but that’s the price we pay for the immunity to fear. The details vary, but the formula remains the same. If there isn’t some sort of ‘hook’ for our attention (some sort of apparently winnable game that we can play) then there’s no escape for us; the identity needs to validate its existence to itself by engaging in logical tasks and so to remove the hooks is to remove this validation. This is a problem because the concrete identity cannot exist without some kind of ‘mental echo-chamber’ confirming it to itself the whole time. The extrinsic self cannot not have goals, in other words. It can therefore be said that we adhere to the logical surface in order to confirm our identity to ourselves – the more closely we conform to the blueprint that has been provided to us by the system, the more real we feel. The game defines the game-player and being defined is what we want. ‘Being defined’ is what it’s all about – that’s the function of the echo chamber.
It’s to our benefit therefore (when we’re playing the game that is confirming our existence) to conform to the rules as assiduously as we possibly can. In order to obtain the ontological security we crave we have to ‘play the game’ and so play the game we do. Allowing ourselves to be 100% defined by the Tyrant of Logic means that we’re not actually playing the game at all however – it means that the game is playing us. The game is that we’re playing the game, but really the game is playing us. When the external authority of logic gets to say who I am then ‘who I am is’ replaced by ‘who the system says I am’ and so there’s no more ‘I’. There is only this mechanical system, endlessly replicating itself in everything it does, endlessly denying everything that doesn’t match its static categories. There is only the super-aggressive Empire of Thought tirelessly extending itself, tirelessly converting the whole world into its own narrow terms. We obtain the advantage of being ‘fully defined’ by going along with the totalitarian system that’s doing the defining – within the closed context of the simulation we get to feel that our identity is 100% real, 100% valid, 100% solid, and this is security that we’re looking for. This is what we want – this confirmation (the confirmation that is provided by the echo chamber of the thinking mind) is the only thing that can ‘hit the spot’ with regard to ontological certainty, but at the same time there is a drawback to this gimmick that makes the whole endeavour pointless. The drawback derives from the inarguable fact that the external authority is a liar. Nothing it says is ever true, and so its so-called ‘validation’ is hollow.
If we believe the Lie then we get to feel real, we get to feel that we absolutely are this mind-created identity and this identification with the image of who we supposedly are equals ‘freedom from ontological terror’ (which is a paradox since this type of ‘freedom’ only comes about as a result of submitting ourselves to the tyranny of the External Authority). It can therefore be said that we escape ontological terror by believing what the EA tells us, therefore – ‘the more we believe the safer we feel’. It doesn’t matter what type of belief it is that we might be adhering to, therefore, it’s simply fear in disguise. We believe whatever it is we believe for the purpose of evading this fear, and no matter what the characteristics of our belief system might be, the one thing we know for sure (the only thing we know for sure) is that all beliefs are lies. The truth is that we’re so busy running away from what we are so busy running away from and our pet beliefs are the way I’m avoiding it, our way of hiding from it. The truth doesn’t give us anywhere to hide – “The birds have their nests and foxes have their burrows, but the son of man has nowhere to rest his head”. [Matthew 8:20] When we talk about ‘the need to belong’, ‘the need to fit in’, ‘the need to be approved of’, etc, this is what we’re talking about – we are referencing this terrible need for ontological security, this terrible craving for someone (or something) to tell us who we are so that we don’t have to worry our heads about it, so there won’t be any doubt there, gnawing away at our innards.
The truth doesn’t give us anywhere to hide, and so if it’s hiding that we’re after then we’re going to have to turn our backs on the truth. This is the way fear shows itself in the world, therefore – it shows itself in the spectacle of people who are committed to turning their backs on what is true. This is fear’s ‘behavioural manifestation’ – it manifests itself in the behaviour of [1] avoiding seeing the truth, and [2] avoiding seeing that this is what we are doing (since to see that we’re avoiding the truth would be to confront that very truth, would be to see it head on). The effect of fear on us is thus invisible – we don’t generally go around looking afraid – on the contrary, we come across as being perfectly confident, perfectly self-assured, perfectly at ease, and so on. This is the theatre, this is the show that is being put on, and the way in which we hide from the Fear that is out there waiting to stomp us is by pretending very hard that this show is not a show, but the way things genuinely are. If escaping fear is what we want (which it is) then our ‘job’ is to be forever optimising our game so that we get better and better at approximating the theatrical image; the more closely we approximate image the more confident we will become. What we call ‘confidence’ is therefore a measure of how well adapted we are to the flat-plane surface that is provided for us by logic. The more adapted we are to this surface the more divorced from reality we become, the more deluded we become. The better we are at playing the game the more certain of ourselves we are. What we call ‘confidence’ is therefore a measure of our ability to be convinced by our performance in the game. The flat-plane surface is an abstraction however, the game only a pretence.